The first in an occasional series of musings on aspects of the Music Library collection by Rod Sharpe, Music Librarian (rl-sharpe @ wiu.edu).
Lists!

Most people seem to be fascinated by lists; the 10 or 100 best (or worst) of this or that. Musicians are no different. We have in our collection The Book of Classical Music Lists by Herbert Kupferberg (Reference ML63.K88 1985). It gives, among other things, a list of the names of Johann Sebastian Bachās twenty children! Most record labels recycle their old recordings by packaging them under some rubric such as Laserlightās 100 Masterpieces of Classical Music.

In a recent addition to our books collection, āLife and Death of Classical Musicā (MUSIC. ML3790 .L439 2007), the author, Norman Lebrecht, lists what he considers to be the 100 best classical recordings ever made. This is a presumptive and subjective exercise, of course, and he takes up half the book justifying his pick. If I were to compile my own list there would probably be some he and I shared in common but Iād end up with a quite different list. However, I was just curious to find out how many of his picks the Music Library owns.
It turns out we own 41 out of the 100 recordings on Lebrechtās list (weāve included the call numbers so that you can check āem out). A few more are available through our streaming audio database Naxos Music Library. This may not seem like a very high percentage, but bear in mind that the criterion for inclusion is the quality of the performances not the repertoire itself. I dare say we own virtually all of the music on his list.
I also had to hand a list of the Top 100 Jazz CDs; The Best Ever Released on CD, although I donāt remember off-hand where I found it. Of these, we own 38. Check out the list.
I mentioned above what my 100 best picks of classical recordings might be like. I wonāt bore you with that many but Iāll give you, off the top of my head, what are my top 10 favorites at the moment. Of course, by tomorrow I would probably come up with a totally different list. Just for fun, I invite you to do the same; post your current 10 favorite recordings (and add a call number if the library owns it so that others can check it out).
Rodās 10 favorite recordings:
- Puccini. Madama Butterfly. Victoria de los Angeles: Cio-Cio-San; John Lanigan: B.F. Pinkerton; Geraint Evans: Sharpless; Chorus & Orchestra of the Royal Opera House Covent Garden, conducted by Rudolf Kempe (live, 2 May 1957) ROSH006 [MCD1500 .P83 M32 K45 2007]
- Schubert. String Quartet No. 15 in G, D887. Vegh Quartet (live, 10/8/1968)
- Strauss, Johann II. Die Fledermaus. Julius Patzak (Tenor), Hilde Gueden (Soprano), Wilma Lipp (Soprano), Anton Dermota (Tenor), Kurt Preger (Baritone), Alfred Poell (Baritone), Sieglinde Wagner (Mezzo Soprano), August Jaresch (Tenor);
Vienna Philharmonic Orchestra, Vienna Philharmonic Chorus conducted by Clemens Krauss
- Britten. Missa Brevis. Boys of Westminster Cathedral Choir directed by George Malcolm (live, 1959)
- Mozart. Piano Concerto No. 25, K.503. Alfred Brendel (piano), Vienna Pro Musica Orchestra conducted by Paul Angerer. [MD1610 .M693 K.503 T8]
- Elgar. Sea Pictures, Op. 37. Janet Baker (mezzo-soprano), London Symphony Orchestra conducted by Sir John Barbirolli.
- Stravinsky. Octet for Wind Instruments. Prague Chamber Harmony
- Dvorak. Slavonic Dances, Op. 46 & Op. 72. Czech Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Vaclav Talich
- Purcell, Dido & Aeneas. Tatiana Troyanos, Felicity Palmer, Richard Stilwell, etc., English Chamber Choir & Orchestra conducted by Raymond Leppard.
- Werner. Hirtenkantate zur Christnach. Lisa Otto, Sieglinde Wagner, Theo Altmeyer, Theo Adam, Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra conducted by Karl Forster
Looking over this list, Iām shocked, of course that thereās no Beethoven , Haydn, Ravel, or Janacek there, just for a start. And of all the Elgar that I love, why pick a lesser work like Sea Pictures? And why include a piece by the relatively obscure Austrian composer Gregor Joseph Werner? Well, as I said above, itās all about the performances. These are all recordings that make the hair on the back of my neck stand up! If I had compiled my 10 favorite pieces rather than recordings it would have been a different list (most of them by Schubert!).
COMPETITION
A number of operatic characters die by drowning. Submit a list with the name of the character and the name of the opera. There is a prize of a $10 gift certificate from the Union Bookstore for the person who can come up with the longest list!